Review of the Bollywood Controversial Film "The Sabarmati Report"
"The Sabarmati Report," released on November 15, 2024, is a Hindi-language political drama directed by Dheeraj Sarna and produced by Ekta Kapoor's Balaji Motion Pictures. The film delves into the harrowing events of the 2002 Godhra train burning incident, focusing on the Sabarmati Express tragedy. With a cast led by Vikrant Massey, Raashii Khanna, and Riddhi Dogra, the movie aims to shed light on a pivotal moment in Indian history.
Plot Overview
The narrative centres on Samar Kumar (Vikrant Massey), a vernacular photojournalist determined to uncover the truth behind the Godhra incident. Collaborating with investigative journalist Amrita Gill (Raashii Khanna) and legal expert Manika Rajpurohit (Riddhi Dogra), Samar navigates a complex web of political intrigue, media sensationalism, and societal tensions. The film portrays their relentless pursuit of justice, highlighting the challenges faced by journalists and the ethical dilemmas inherent in reporting sensitive events.
Performances
Vikrant Massey's portrayal of Samar Kumar has been widely praised for its authenticity and depth. His ability to convey the emotional turmoil of a journalist entrenched in such a contentious issue adds a compelling layer to the film. Raashii Khanna delivers a strong performance as Amrita Gill, embodying the determination and resilience of an investigative journalist. Riddhi Dogra's depiction of Manika Rajpurohit provides a nuanced perspective on the legal challenges surrounding the case.
Know More:
Direction and Screenplay
Dheeraj Sarna's direction is commendable for its attempt to balance a sensitive historical event with the demands of cinematic storytelling. The screenplay, penned by Arjun Bhandegaonkar, Avinash Singh Tomar, and Vipin Agnihotri, strives to present a factual account while maintaining narrative engagement. However, some critics have noted that the film occasionally leans towards dramatisation, potentially compromising the authenticity of the depicted events.
Cinematography and Music
Amalendu Chaudhary's cinematography captures the tense atmosphere surrounding the Godhra incident, utilising a muted colour palette to reflect the gravity of the subject matter. The film's music, composed by Kartik Kush, Akhil Sachdeva, Anu Malik, and Arko, complements the narrative, with the background score enhancing the emotional resonance of key scenes.
Know More:
Critical Reception
"The Sabarmati Report" has elicited mixed reactions from critics. Shubhra Gupta of The Indian Express rated the film 1.5 stars out of 5, commenting that it "has no nuance, just judgement." Pankaj Shukla from Amar Ujala also awarded it 1.5 stars, criticising the film for attempting to capitalise on Vikrant Massey's fame and pointing out inaccuracies in the usage of Hindi.
Conversely, Amit Bhatia from ABP News gave the film 3.5 stars, praising its bold approach to the subject matter and its layered portrayal of journalism intersecting with politics and public opinion. Lachmi Deb Roy from First Post echoed this sentiment, describing the film as a "well-researched story and a sharply made film" that avoids unnecessary melodrama.
Nishad Thaivalappil from CNN-News18 also rated the film 3.5 stars, commending the dialogue, background score, and Massey's performance. Sakshi Verma of India TV awarded it 3 stars, finding the performances commendable and noting that the film remains engaging throughout.
Know More:
Mixed to Negative Feedback
However, Zinia Bandyopadhyay from India Today rated the film 2 stars, calling it an honest attempt that is marred by several issues, including an overemphasis on the vernacular vs. English journalists' angle. Bollywood Hungama also gave it 1.5 stars, praising the lead performances and production design but criticising its "haphazard execution" and loose script.
Controversies
The film has not been without controversy. During the trailer launch event, Vikrant Massey revealed that he had received threats related to his involvement in the project, which addresses the Godhra train burning incident. Despite these challenges, Massey affirmed the film's commitment to presenting factual content.
The political undertones of The Sabarmati Report have sparked debates across social media platforms. Some audiences perceive it as an essential cinematic reminder of historical truth, while others accuse it of stirring old wounds. The film’s depiction of journalistic ethics and political pressure has also initiated conversations on the media’s role in shaping public perception. Such controversy has arguably contributed to the film’s visibility, drawing curious audiences eager to witness its interpretation of one of India’s most sensitive events.
Know More:
Box Office Performance and Audience Response
Commercially, The Sabarmati Report opened to moderate box-office collections. Despite the mixed critical reception, it managed to attract a steady audience base, particularly in metropolitan cities. Many viewers appreciated its courage to tackle a topic rarely explored in mainstream cinema. On social media, hashtags such as #TheSabarmatiReport and #VikrantMassey trended during its first week of release, reflecting the film’s cultural impact.
Audiences have praised the film’s effort to initiate dialogue around historical accountability and truth in journalism. However, others have pointed out that certain creative liberties dilute the factual core of the story. Overall, the film remains a talking point among cinephiles who admire politically conscious storytelling.
Conclusion
"The Sabarmati Report" is a film that tackles a significant and sensitive chapter in Indian history. While it boasts strong performances and a compelling narrative, the film's reception indicates a divide between its intentions and execution. For viewers interested in political dramas and historical events, it offers a perspective on the complexities of journalism, politics, and societal tensions in the aftermath of the Godhra incident. However, potential viewers should be aware of the mixed critical responses and approach the film with an understanding of its dramatised portrayal of real events.
Ultimately, The Sabarmati Report stands as a bold attempt in contemporary Hindi cinema to revisit a painful period in India’s history. It encourages reflection on truth, bias, and the responsibility of storytelling in a politically charged society. Whether one agrees with its interpretation or not, the film successfully reignites a discussion on justice, truth, and reconciliation — themes that remain relevant even decades after the events it depicts.
Social Plugin